Competition of Legal Norms in the Russian Church from the 10th to 13th Centuries? Tithe and Weregild

Vinogradov, Andrey

doi:10.18254/S207987840025778-4

English

Home>Issue 6 (128)>Competition of Legal Norms in the Russian Church from the 10th to 13th Centuries? Tithe and Weregild

Competition of Legal Norms in the Russian Church from the 10th to 13th Centuries? Tithe and Weregild

Table of contents

Annotation Estimate Publication content

References Comments

Competition of Legal Norms in the Russian Church from the 10th to 13th Centuries? Tithe and Weregild

Annotation

PII

S207987840025778-4-1

DOI

10.18254/S207987840025778-4

Publication type

Article

Status

Published

Authors

Andrey Vinogradov Send message

ORCID: 0000-0002-9516-6534

Affiliation: Higher School of Economics
Address: Russian Federation, Moscow

Edition

Volume 14 Issue 6 (128)

Abstract

The article discusses two key differences between pre-Mongol Rus’ and Byzantium in the field of church legal institutions. The author shows that the introduction of tithes from princely incomes instead of fixed payments for the churches was provoked by the absence of the Greek hierarchy in Russia at the moment of the consecration of the Kiev Tithe Cathedral in 995–996, as well as by only partially monetary nature of the Old Russian economy and the general crisis of the Byzantine model of financial support for the Church. However, it was part of civil legislation and did not contradicted Byzantine canon law. However, the practice of monetary penalties for sins introduced by Yaroslav Vladimirovich directly contradicted not only the canons of the Eastern Church, but also the essence of its law. They were introduced to make it easier for newly baptized Russia to adopt the norms of Christian morality by likening punishments for its violations to monetary penalties for civil crimes, which also distinguished the legal system of Old Rus’ (as well as Northern Europe) from the Greco-Roman one.

Keywords

church law, tithe, penalties, penance, Old Rus’, Byzantium, Western Europe

Received

24.05.2023

Publication date

28.08.2023

Number of characters

55855

Number of purchasers

Views

237

Readers community rating

0.0 (0 votes)

Cite Download pdf 200 RUB / 1.0 SU

To download PDF you should pay the subscribtion

GOST	Vinogradov A. Competition of Legal Norms in the Russian Church from the 10th to 13th Centuries? Tithe and Weregild // ISTORIYA. – 2023. – V. 14. – Issue 6 (128). URL: https://history.jes.su/s207987840025778-4-1/. DOI: 10.18254/S207987840025778-4
MLA	Vinogradov, Andrey "Competition of Legal Norms in the Russian Church from the 10th to 13th Centuries? Tithe and Weregild." ISTORIYA. 14.6 (128) (2023). DOI: 10.18254/S207987840025778-4
APA	Vinogradov A. (2023). Competition of Legal Norms in the Russian Church from the 10th to 13th Centuries? Tithe and Weregild. ISTORIYA. vol. 14, no. 6 (128) DOI: 10.18254/S207987840025778-4

Full text is available to subscribers only

Subscribe right now

Only article and additional services

Subscription benefits

200 RUB / 1.0 SU

Whole issue and additional services

Subscription benefits

820 RUB / 10.0 SU

All issues and additional services for 2023

Subscription benefits

5000 RUB / 50.0 SU

References

1. Abramovich D. I. Kievo-Pecherskij paterik. Kiev, 1991.

2. Artamonov Yu. A. Kto v Drevnej Rusi mog rasschityvat' na poluchenie desyatiny? // Rus' ehpokhi Vladimira Velikogo: gosudarstvo, tserkov', kul'tura: materialy Mezhdunarodnoj nauchnoj konferentsii v pamyat' tysyacheletiya konchiny svyatogo ravnoapostol'nogo knyazya Vladimira i muchenicheskogo podviga svyatykh knyazej Borisa i Gleba, Moskva, 14—16 oktyabrya 2015 g. / otv. red. N. A. Makarov, A. V. Nazarenko. M.; Vologda, 2017. S. 229—241.

3. Vinogradov A. Yu. O khronologii russkikh mitropolitov XI v. (po povodu novoj gipotezy A. P. Tolochko) // Slovene. 2019. T. 8. № 1. S. 477—485.

4. Vinogradov A. Yu. Rol' arkhiepiskopa Nifonta v novgorodskikh sobytiyakh 1136 g. // Slovene. 2022. T. 11. S. 472—476.

5. Vinogradov A., Zheltov M. Life and Death of Theodorets of Vladimir: Justice or Reprisal? // ISTORIYA. 2019. Vol. 10. Is. 10 (84). URL: https://history.jes.su/s207987840008052-6-1/ DOI: 10.18254/S207987840008052-6

6. Gippius A. A. K istorii slozheniya teksta Novgorodskoj pervoj letopisi. Spornye voprosy tekstologii NPL // Novgorodskij istoricheskij sbornik. 1997. Vyp. 6. S. 3—72.

7. Gippius A. A. Zagadki Mstislavovoj gramoty // Miscellanea Slavica: sbornik statej k 70-letiyu B. A. Uspenskogo. M., 2008. S. 109—129.

8. Gippius A. A., Drobysheva M. M. «Ruga» v graffito № 9 Sofii Kievskoj // Vostochnaya Evropa v drevnosti i srednevekov'e. Chteniya pamyati chlena-korrespondenta AN SSSR Vladimira Terent'evicha Pashuto. Vyp. XXKhII. Sravnitel'nye issledovaniya sotsiokul'turnykh praktik / otv. red. E. A. Mel'nikova. M., 2020. S. 58—65.

9. Gippius A. A., Drobysheva M. M. «Prishestvie Svyatoslava»: kievskoe graffito № 9 i ego istoricheskij kontekst // Rossijskaya istoriya. 2022. № 5. S. 3—18.

10. Grekov B. D. Izbrannye trudy. T. 4. M., 1960.

11. Znamenskij P. V. Prikhodskoe dukhovenstvo na Rusi. Povinnosti dukhovenstva v drevnej Rusi // Pravoslavnoe obozrenie. 1867. T. 28. S. 181—221.

12. Karamzin N. M. Istoriya gosudarstva Rossijskogo. 3-e izd. T. 2. SPb., 1830.

13. Kloss B. M., Lur'e Ya. S. Russkie letopisi XI—XV vv. // Metodicheskie rekomendatsii po opisaniyu slavyano-russkikh rukopisej dlya Svodnogo kataloga rukopisej, khranyaschikhsya v SSSR. M., 1976. Vyp. 2. S. 113—122.

14. Klyuchevskij V. O. Sochineniya. T. 1. M., 1956.

15. Kostromin K. A. Proiskhozhdenie i funktsiya drevnerusskoj tserkovnoj desyatiny i zapadnoevropejskie analogi // Paleorosiya. Drevnyaya Rus' vo vremeni, v lichnostyakh, v ideyakh. 2014. № 1. S. 35—62.

16. Kuleshov V. S. Pis'mennye i numizmaticheskie istochniki po istorii denezhnogo obrascheniya v Vostochnoj Evrope v IX—XI vv. Avtoreferat diss. … kand. ist. nauk. Moskva, 2019.

17. Milov L. V. Issledovaniya po istorii pamyatnikov srednevekovogo prava. M., 2009.

18. Milyutenko N. I. Svyatoj ravnoapostol'nyj knyaz' Vladimir i Kreschenie Rusi. Drevnejshie pis'mennye istochniki. SPb., 2008.

19. Nazarenko A. V. O vremeni uchrezhdeniya Kievskoj mitropolii (sovremennoe sostoyanie problemy) // Rus' ehpokhi Vladimira Velikogo: gosudarstvo, tserkov', kul'tura: materialy Mezhdunarodnoj nauchnoj konferentsii v pamyat' tysyacheletiya konchiny svyatogo ravnoapostol'nogo knyazya Vladimira i muchenicheskogo podviga svyatykh knyazej Borisa i Gleba, Moskva, 14—16 oktyabrya 2015 g. / otv. red. N. A. Makarov, A. V. Nazarenko. M.; Vologda, 2017. S. 130—175.

20. Pamyatniki drevnerusskogo kanonicheskogo prava. Chast' 1. Pamyatniki XI—XV v.. SPb., 1908.

21. Pamyatniki prava feodal'no-razdroblennoj Rusi XII—XV vv. // Pamyatniki russkogo prava / pod red. S. V. Yushkova, sost. A. A. Zimin. Vyp. 2. M., 1953.

22. Pentkovskij A. M. Pokayannaya distsiplina khristianskoj Tserkvi v kontse I tysyacheletiya // Zhurnal Moskovskoj Patriarkhii. 2002. № 10. S. 63—70.

23. Petrukhin V. Ya. K probleme proiskhozhdeniya drevnerusskoj desyatiny: «Vetkhij zavet» i drevnerusskaya traditsiya // Florilegium: k 60-letiyu B. N. Flori. M., 2000. S. 265—276.

24. Pechnikov M. V. K izucheniyu sobornykh pravil 1273 g. // Drevnyaya Rus'. Voprosy medievistiki. 2009. № 4 (38). S. 97—107.

25. Pechnikov M. V. Novgorodskij svt. Nifont, knyazheskaya vlast' i Kievskaya mitropoliya (30—50-e gg. XII v.) // Vestnik tserkovnoj istorii. 2017. № 3/4 (47/48). S. 250—251.

26. Polnoe sobranie russkikh letopisej. L., 1926. T. I.

27. Polnoe sobranie russkikh letopisej. Petrograd, 1923. T. II (I).

28. Rus' ehpokhi Vladimira Velikogo: gosudarstvo, tserkov', kul'tura: materialy Mezhdunarodnoj nauchnoj konferentsii v pamyat' tysyacheletiya konchiny svyatogo ravnoapostol'nogo knyazya Vladimira i muchenicheskogo podviga svyatykh knyazej Borisa i Gleba, Moskva, 14—16 oktyabrya 2015 g. / otv. red. N. A. Makarov, A. V. Nazarenko. Moskva; Vologda, 2017.

29. Sil'vestrova E. V., Belyakova E. V. Novelly Yustiniana // Pravoslavnaya ehntsiklopediya. T. 51. M., 2001. S. 544—552.

30. Slovar' russkogo yazyka XI—XVII vv. Vyp. 4. M., 1977.

31. Slovar' russkogo yazyka XI—XIV vv. T. 2. M., 1989.

32. Slovar' russkogo yazyka XI—XIV vv. T. 12. M., 2019.

33. Sreznevskij I. I. Materialy dlya Slovarya drevnerusskogo yazyka. T. 3. SPb., 1903.

34. Stefanovich P. S. Grivna kak denezhnaya edinitsa: k sporu «mekhovistov» i «metallistov» // Rossijskij rubl': 700 let istorii. Materialy mezhdunarodnoj nauchnoj konferentsii / otv. red. P. G. Gajdukov. Velikij Novgorod, 2017. S. 19—24.

35. Stefanovich P. S. Prikhod i prikhodskoe dukhovenstvo v Rossii v XVI—XVII vv. M., 2002.

36. Stefanovich P. S. Knyazheskie dokhody i tserkovnaya desyatina po gramotam XII v. // Drevnyaya Rus'. Voprosy medievistiki. 2015. № 3 (61). S. 155—156.

37. Tikhomirov M. N. Krest'yanskie i gorodskie vosstaniya na Rusi XI—XIII vv. M., 1955.

38. Florya B. N. Otnosheniya gosudarstva i tserkvi u vostochnykh i zapadnykh slavyan (ehpokha srednevekov'ya) // Florya B. N. Issledovaniya po istorii Tserkvi. Drevnerusskoe i slavyanskoe srednevekov'e. M., 2007.

39. Froyanov I. Ya. Rabstvo i dannichestvo u vostochnykh slavyan (VI—X vv.). SPb., 1996.

40. Schapov Ya. N. Drevnerusskie knyazheskie ustavy XI—XV vv. M., 1976.

41. Schapov Ya. N. Knyazheskie ustavy i tserkov' v Drevnej Rusi. M., 1982.

42. Schapov Ya. N. Gosudarstvo i tserkov' na Rusi X—XIII vv. M., 1989.

43. Fritzler K. Zwei Abhandlungen uber altrussisches Recht. Berlin; Leipzig, 1923.

44. Herman E. Das bischofliche Abgabenwesen im Patriarchat von Konstantinopel vom XI. bis zur Mitte des XIX. Jahrhunderts // Orientalia christiana periodica. 1939. Bd. 5. S. 437—447.

45. Kendrick T. D. A History of the Vikings. N.Y., 2004.