Life and Death of Theodorets of Vladimir: Justice or Reprisal?
Table of contents
Share
Metrics
Life and Death of Theodorets of Vladimir: Justice or Reprisal?
Annotation
PII
S207987840008052-6-1
DOI
10.18254/S207987840008052-6
Publication type
Article
Status
Published
Authors
Andrey Vinogradov 
Affiliation: Higher School of Economics
Address: Russian Federation, Moscow
Mikhail Zheltov
Affiliation:
Moscow Theological Academy
Sretenskaya Theological Seminary
Address: Russian Federation, Moscow
Abstract

The article gives an attempt to uncover the legal background of extraordinary actions related to Theodore, the pretender to the metropolitan see of Vladimir-on-Klyazma, who was eventually given a derogatory nickname, Theodorets. A Greek presbyter (most probably), once deposed or for some other reason deproved from a church he was assigned to, he either acquired the status of the hypopsephios of Souzdal, or even was actually consecrated as a bishop by Klim Smolyatich. However, despite all attempts of prince Andrey Bogolyubsky to officially install him as a Metropolitan of Vladimir, Theodore’s canonical status was never recognized neither by Constantine II, Metropolitan of Kiev, nor by the then Patriarch of Constantinople, Luke Chrysoberges. Both of the just mentioned Greek hierarchs denied Theodore’s legitimacy and blamed him. Their reasons included his active role in disputes concerning the new fasting rules, introduced by the representatives of the reformed Byzantine monasticism of the time. When prince Andrey realized that his plan to create a Metropolitan see in Vladimir has failed, he decided to send Theodore to Kiev in order to receive proper episcopal consecration from Metropolitan Constantine II. Theodore responded by a refusal to obey, and tried to demonstrate his power instead, blatantly closing all church buildings in Vladimir. In the end, Andrey handed Theodore over to the Metropolitan’s court. Metropolitan Constantine II decided to sue Theodore according the norms of the Byzantine civil law (obviously, considering him as a Byzantine citizen), and since the charges against Theodore included heresy, he was condemned to brutal physical injuries and, finally, death. Afterwards the body of the unsuccessful contender to a metropolitan throne was thrown to the dogs, in order to get a symbolical closure on his story.

Keywords
Old Rus’, Russian Church, Byzantine civil law, Orthodox canon law Metropolitans of Kiev, Patriarchate of Constantinople, fasting, punishment, Andrey Bogolyubsky
Received
17.10.2019
Publication date
15.12.2019
Number of characters
43382
Number of purchasers
3
Views
36
Readers community rating
0.0 (0 votes)
Cite Download pdf 100 RUB / 1.0 SU

To download PDF you should sign in

Full text is available to subscribers only
Subscribe right now
Only article
100 RUB / 1.0 SU
Whole issue
1000 RUB / 10.0 SU
All issues for 2019
2500 RUB / 50.0 SU

References

1. Troianos S. Die Strafen im byzantinischen Recht. Eine Übersicht // Jahrbuch der österreichischen Byzantinistik. 1992. Bd. 42. S. 55—74.

2. Vinogradov A. Yu., Zheltov M. S. «Zaveschanie» mitropolita Konstantina I Kievskogo i kanon «na iskhod dushi» // Slovҍne — Slověne: International Journal of Slavic Studies. 2014. № 3:1. S. 43—71.

3. Vinogradov A. Yu., Zheltov M. S. «Pervaya eres' na Rusi»: russkie spory 1160-kh godov ob otmene posta v prazdnichnye dni // Drevnyaya Rus'. 2018. № 3 (73). S. 118—139.

4. Vinogradov A. Yu., Zheltov M. S. Pravovye akty Russkoj mitropolii pri Konstantine Ι (1156—1159 gg.) // U istokov i istochnikov: na mezhdunarodnykh i mezhdistsiplinarnykh putyakh. Yubilejnyj sbornik v chest' Aleksandra Vasil'evicha Nazarenko. M., 2018. S. 35—56.

5. Vinogradov A. Yu., Zheltov M. S., svyasch. Tserkovnaya politika Konstantinopol'skoj patriarkhii pri Manuile I Komnine i krizis Russkoj mitropolii v 1156—1169 gg. // EhNOZh «Istoriya». 2019 (v pechati).

6. Voronin N. N. Andrej Bogolyubskij i Luka Khrizoverg: Iz istorii russko-vizantijskikh otnoshenij XII v. // Vizantijskij vremennik. 1962. T. 21. S. 29—50.

7. Gippius A. A. Kleveta na episkopa Luku: Ehpigraficheskie svidetel'stva letopisnogo ehpizoda? // Trudy Otdela drevnerusskoj literatury. SPb., 2016. T. LXVI. S. 806—817.

8. Eremin I. P. Pritcha o sleptse i khromtse v drevnerusskoj pis'mennosti // Izvestiya otdeleniya russkogo yazyka i slovesnosti Akademii nauk SSSR 1925 g. L., 1926. T. 30. S. 323—352.

9. Eremin I. P. Literaturnoe nasledie Kirilla Turovskogo, I: Kirilla mnikha pritcha o chelovѣchstѣj dushi i o telesi... // Trudy otdela drevnerusskoj literatury. L., 1956. T. 12. S. 340—361.

10. Loseva O. V. Zhitiya russkikh svyatykh v sostave drevnerusskikh prologov XII — pervoj treti XV vekov. M., 2009.

11. Makarij (Bulgakov'), mitr. Istoriya Russkoj Tserkvi. SPb., 1870. T. III.

12. Mil'kov V. V. Novgorodskij svyatitel' Luka: kharakter deyatel'nosti i idejnye aspekty tvorchestva // Novgorodskaya zemlya v ehpokhu Yaroslava Mudrogo. Velikij Novgorod, 2010. S. 209—211.

13. Nazarenko A. V. Nesostoyavshayasya mitropoliya (ob odnom iz tserkovno-politicheskikh proektov Andreya Bogolyubskogo) // «Khvalam dostojnyj...»: Andrej Bogolyubskij v russkoj istorii i kul'ture. Mezhdunarodnaya nauchnaya konferentsiya (Vladimir, 5—6 iyulya 2011 g.). Vladimir, 2013. S. 13—36.

14. Nazarenko A. V. Koe-chto o dvukh russkikh mitropolitakh XI v. — Efreme Kievskom i Efreme Pereyaslavskom // Drevnyaya Rus'. 2019. № 1 (75). S. 87—90.

15. Parnikoza I. Yu. Kievskie ostrova i pribrezhnye urochischa na Dnepre — vzglyad skvoz' veka. K., 2013—2017 [Ehlektronnyj resurs]. URL: http://www.myslenedrevo.com.ua/ru/Sci/Kyiv/Islands/History/AncientRus/Obolon-et-al-Rus.html.

16. Poppeh A. Mitropolity i knyaz'ya Kievskoj Rusi // Podskal'ski G. Khristianstvo i bogoslovskaya literatura v Kievskoj Rusi (988—1237 gg.). SPb., 1996. S. 457—458.

17. Sokolov' P. [P.] Russkij arkhierej iz' Vizantii i pravo ego naznacheniya do nachala XV vѣka. K., 1913.

18. Stepanenko V. P. «Goroda na Dunae» v kontekste russko-vizantijskikh otnoshenij X—XII v. // Rus' i Vizantiya: Mesto stran vizantijskogo kruga vo vzaimootnosheniyakh Vostoka i Zapada (Tezisy dokladov XVIII Vserossijskoj nauchnoj sessii vizantinistov. Moskva, 20—21 oktyabrya 2008 goda). M., 2008. S. 129—133.

19. Tolochko A. P. Klim Smolyatich posle nizverzheniya iz mitropolii // Khoroshie dni: Pamyati A. S. Khorosheva. Vel. Novgorod; SPb.; M., 2009. S. 548—549.

20. Uspenskij B. A. Mitropolit Kliment Smolyatich i ego poslaniya // Slověne — Slovѣne: International Journal of Slavic Studies. 2017. T. 6. № 1. S. 171—218.