The Search for Identity in the Era of Nationalism: Discussions about the “Muslim” and “Turkic-Tatar” Nation among Russian Volga-Ural Tatars in the early 20th Century
Table of contents
Share
Metrics
The Search for Identity in the Era of Nationalism: Discussions about the “Muslim” and “Turkic-Tatar” Nation among Russian Volga-Ural Tatars in the early 20th Century
Annotation
PII
S207987840002441-4-1
DOI
10.18254/S0002441-4-1
Publication type
Article
Status
Published
Authors
Dilara Usmanova 
Affiliation: Kazan Federal University
Address: Russian Federation, Kazan
Abstract
The article analyzes the public discussion among the Volga-Ural Tatars of the Russian Empire at the beginning of the 20th century which took place on the pages of Tatar periodicals, mainly the magazines Shura (Council) and Aң (Consciousness), as well as in individual works and popular brochures (J. Validi's essay “The Nation and Nationality”). The review of these discussions allows us to analyze the views of a number of Tatar intellectuals of the early 20th century on the process of formation of the ethnic self-consciousness of the Tatar people, their vision of the ways of development of the Tatar nation, the means and methods of its “construction”, and also ways of overcoming various obstacles to the successful preservation and reproduction of the Tatar national identity.
Keywords
Russian Empire, Muslim Ummah, Muslim deputies, State Duma, Volga-Ural Tatars, ethnonym, nation, millat, discussion, press, Gaziz Gubaidullin, Jamal Validi
Received
22.06.2018
Publication date
28.09.2018
Number of characters
34708
Number of purchasers
43
Views
1808
Readers community rating
0.0 (0 votes)
Cite Download pdf 100 RUB / 1.0 SU

To download PDF you should sign in

Full text is available to subscribers only
Subscribe right now
Only article
100 RUB / 1.0 SU
Whole issue
1000 RUB / 10.0 SU
All issues for 2018
2500 RUB / 50.0 SU

References

1. Adam Volker. Zur Diskussion um Sprache und türkische Identität in der aserbaidschanischen Presse (1903-1914). In: Ural-Altaische Jahrbücher. 2001/2002. Band 17. S. 128-155.

2. Andriewsky Olga. The politics of national identity: the ukrainian question in Russia. 1904-1912. Harvard University. Ph.D. Diss., 1991. 499 pp.

3. Altstadt A.L. The Azerbaijani Turks. Power and Identity under Russian Rule. Stanford: Hoover Institutions Press, 1992. 331 p.

4. Khalid Adeeb. The Politics of Muslim Cultural Reform: Jadidism in Central Asia. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1998. 335 p.

5. Maksudi-Arsal Sadri Milliyet duygusunun sosyolojik esaslar? Istanbul, 1955.

6. Noack Christian, Muslimischer Nationalismus im Russischen Reich. Nationsbildung und Nationsbewegung bei Tataren und Baschkiren, 1861 – 1917. Stuttgart, 2000. 614 S.

7. Swietochowski T. Russian Azerbaijan, 1905 – 1920. The shaping of national identity in a muslim community. Cambridge, London, New York. Cambridge University Press, 1985. 256 pp.

8. Ajda Adile, Sadri Maksudi Arsal. M., 1996. 357 s.

9. Ashnin F.D, Alpatov V.M. Gibel' professora Gubajdullina // Altaica. 1998. № 2. S. 5-17.

10. Ashnin F.D., Alpatov V.M., Nasilov D.M. Repressirovannaya tyurkologiya. M.: Vostochnaya literatura RAN, 2002.

11. Validi Dzh. “U menya raznoglasiya s sovvlast'yu...” // Җamal Vәlidi. Әdәbi һәm tarikhi-dokumental' җyentyk. Kazan: Җyen, 2010. S. 534-572.

12. Validi Dzh. Ocherki istorii literatury i obrazovannosti tatar do revolyutsii 1917 goda. M.—L., 1923.

13. Vәlidi Җamal. Millәt vә milliyat. Kazan', 1914. 50 s.

14. Gaziz G. (= Gaziz Gөbәjdullin). Millәtchelekneң bәg'ze әsaslary. Kazan, 1918.

15. Gaziz Gөbәjdullin: fәnni-biografik җyentyk. Kazan: Җyen, 2002. 336 s.

16. Gali Rәkhim: Tarikhi-dokumental' җyentyk. Kazan: Җyen, 2008. 479 s.

17. Gaffarova F.Yu. Sadri Maksudi (1906—1924 ellar). Kazan', 2001. 262 s.

18. Gosmanov M.A. Җamal Vәlidi: Yazmyshy һәm uryny, yaki onyttyrylgan oly miras (Dzhamal Validi: sud'ba i mesto v istorii, ili zhe vynuzhdenno zabytoe ogromnoe nasledie) // Җamal Vәlidi. Әdәbi һәm tarikhi-dokumental' җyentyk. (“Shәkheslәrebez” seriyase). Kazan: Җyen, 2010. 9-34 bb.

19. Җamal Vәlidi. Әdәbi һәm tarikhi-dokumental' җyentyk. Kazan: Җyen, 2010. 623 s.

20. Җamal Vәlidi: Sajlanma khezmәtlәr. Kazan: Mәgarif, 2007. 271 s.

21. Ibragimov M., Kiyamova A., Problema natsional'nogo v trudakh tatarskikh uchenykh i publitsistov nachala KhKh veka // Filologiya i kul'tura. Philology and Culture. 2016. № 1 (43). S. 212-217.

22. Ibraһimov G. Millәt. Tel. Әdәbiyat: Sajlanma khөzmәtlәr. Kazan: Mәgarif, 2007. S. 9-14.

23. Istoriya tatar s drevnejshikh vremen v semi tomakh. Tom VII. Tatary i Tatarstan v XX – nachale KhKhI v. Kazan': Institut istorii im. Sh. Mardzhani AN RT, 2013. S. 218-249.

24. Iskhakov D. Ehtnicheskoe razvitie volgo-ural'skikh tatar v XV – nachale XX vv. Dissertatsiya v vide nauchnogo doklada na soiskanie uchenoj stepeni doktora istoricheskikh nauk. M., 2000.

25. Iskhakov S.M. Obscherossijskaya partiya musul'man // Istoriya natsional'nykh politicheskikh partij Rossii: Materialy konferentsii. M., 1997. S. 214—239.

26. Kostyrchenko G. V. Natsional'nyj vopros v SSSR v svete zapadnoj «novoimperskoj» istoriografii // Ehlektronnyj nauchno-obrazovatel'nyj zhurnal «Istoriya». 2014. T. 5. Vypusk 4 (27). URL: http://history.jes.su/s207987840000733-5-1

27. Mustafin R. Tragediya Dzhamala Validi // Tatarstan. 1997. № 12.

28. Musul'manskie deputaty Gosudarstvennoj dumy Rossii. 1906—1917 gg. Sbornik dokumentov i materialov / sost. L. A. Yamaeva. Ufa, 1998.

29. Sagitova L. V. Ehtnosotsiologiya i natsional'naya politika. Uchebno-metodicheskoe posobie. Kazan': Tsentr innovatsionnykh tekhnologij, 2005.

30. Samojlovich A. Tatarin o tatarakh // Vostochnyj sbornik. Kniga II. Petrograd, 1916. S. 71-85.

31. Tishkov V. A. Primordializm // Bol'shaya Rossijskaya ehntsiklopediya. M.: Bol'shaya rossijskaya ehntsiklopediya, 2015. S. 498-499.

32. Usmanova D. M. Musul'manskie predstaviteli v rossijskom parlamente. 1906 – 1916. Kazan', 2005. 584 s.

33. Usmanova D.M. Khadi Atlasi v Gosudarstvennoj dume: opyt parlamentskoj deyatel'nosti rossijskogo musul'manina // Khadi Atlasi: istoriko-dokumental'nyj sbornik. Kazan', 2007. S. 281–301.

34. Usmanova D.M. Shkola politiki «natsional'noj gruppy». Musul'manskaya fraktsiya Gosudarstvennoj dumy Rossijskoj imperii // Kazan'. 2006. № 3. S. 36—40.

35. Usmanova D.M. Vserossijskie musul'manskie s'ezdy 1905 – 1907 gg. i obrazovanie Musul'manskogo soyuza «Ittifak al'-muslimin» // Istoriya tatar s drevnejshikh vremen v semi tomakh. Tom VII. Tatary i Tatarstan v XX – nachale KhKhI v. Kazan': Institut istorii im. Sh. Mardzhani AN RT, 2013. S. 78-83.

36. Usmanova D.M. Musul'manskie deputaty v Gosudarstvennoj dume (1906 – 1917): novaya politicheskaya ehlita v Rossijskoj imperii? // Uchenye zapiski Kazanskogo universiteta. Tom 155, kn. 3, ch. 1. Seriya Gumanitarnye nauki. 2013. S. 113-124.

37. Usmanova D.M. Parlamentskaya deyatel'nost' Gabderashita Ibragima: mif ili real'nost'? // Gabderashit Ibragim: nauchno-biograficheskij sbornik (na tatarskom yazyke). Kazan': izd-vo «Zhyen», 2011. S. 311-330.

38. Usmanova D.M. Sozdavaya natsional'nuyu istoriyu tatar: istoriograficheskie i intellektual'nye debaty na rubezhe vekov // Ab imperio. 2003. № 3. S. 335-359.

39. Usmanova D.M. Sozdavaya natsional'nuyu istoriyu tatar: istoriograficheskie i intellektual'nye debaty na rubezhe vekov // Novaya imperskaya istoriya postsovetskogo prostranstva: Sbornik statej (Biblioteka zhurnala “Ab imperio”) / Pod red. I.V. Gerasimova, S.V. Glebova, A. P. Kaplunovskogo, M.B. Mogil'ner, A.M. Semenova. Kazan': “Tsentr Issledovanij Natsionalizma i Imperii”, 2004. S. 109–126.

40. Khәsәn Gali Җ. Vәlidi turynda // Җamal Vәlidi. Әdәbi һәm tarikhi-dokumental' җyentyk. (“Shәkheslәrebez” seriyase). Kazan: Җyen, 2010. S. 531-533.

41. Yamaeva L.A. Musul'manskij liberalizm nachala KhKh veka kak obschestvenno-politicheskoe dvizhenie (po materialam Ufimskoj i Orenburgskoj gubernij). Ufa, 2002. 300 s.