Везде
A Good and a Bad Deception: When Kings, Knights and the People Lye
Table of contents
Annotation Estimate Publication content
References Comments
Share
QR
Metrics
A Good and a Bad Deception: When Kings, Knights and the People Lye
Annotation
PII
S207987840002401-0-1
DOI
10.18254/S0002401-0-1
Publication type
Article
Status
Published
Authors
Alexander Marey 
ORCID: 0000-0001-6185-0453
Occupation: Associate Professor
Affiliation: Higher School of Economics
Address: Russian Federation, Moscow
Edition
Volume 9 Issue 9 (73)
Abstract
In the article is analysing the conception of good and bad deception and the different disciplinary regimes of the fraud described in the Siete Partidas of Alphonse the Wise (1252—1284). The author stresses the point that the lies were permitted only for physical persons meanwhile the political entities (such as a people or a king in his relations with the people) would not lie. That can be explained by the different discursive strategies used by the authors of the Siete Partidas: the laws of the Seventh Partida as laws about chivalry (Part. II.21) were composed by jurists and the norms about a King and his people the theologists had written. For making this analysis more complete in the article, the author gives a brief introduction to the history of the juridical and theological discourses about the lie. He shows the evolution of the interpretation of the concept of the deception from the Late Antiquity to the Law Middle Ages. The author stresses that the Augustinian conception of the lie was the most influent until, at least, a middle 13th century.
Keywords
Lie, Deception, Fraud, Siete Partidas, Castile, Alphonse the Wise, Knighthood, King, People
Received
15.06.2018
Publication date
31.10.2018
Number of characters
39919
Number of purchasers
43
Views
5027
Readers community rating
0.0 (0 votes)
Cite Download pdf 200 RUB / 1.0 SU

To download PDF you should pay the subscribtion

Full text is available to subscribers only
Subscribe right now
Only article and additional services
Subscription benefits
200 RUB / 1.0 SU
Whole issue and additional services
Subscription benefits
800 RUB / 10.0 SU
All issues and additional services for 2018
Subscription benefits
2500 RUB / 50.0 SU

References

1. Voskobojnikov O. S. Tysyacheletnee tsarstvo (300—1300). Ocherk khristianskoj kul'tury Zapada. M., 2014.

2. Marej A. V. Podarok mitropolita: Rukopis' «Vtoroj Partidy» (Ms. 43—11) iz biblioteki Toledskogo sobora i ee marginalii // EhNOZh «Istoriya». 2017. T. 8. Vypusk 6 (60) [Ehlektronnyj resurs]. Dostup dlya zaregistrirovannykh pol'zovatelej. URL: http://history.jes.su/s207987840001902-1-1 (data obrascheniya: 08.10.2018). DOI: 10.18254/S0001902-1-1.

3. Augustinus Aurelius. Contra mendacium liber unus // PL. 40.

4. Augustinus Aurelius. De Civitate Dei contra Paganos libri XXII // PL. 41.Azo. Summa Codicis et Institutionum. Venetiae, 1489.

5. Augustinus Aurelius. De mendacio liber unus // PL. 40.

6. Baransky Z. G. Language as Sin and Salvation: a lectura of Inferno 18. Albany, 2014.

7. Casagrande S., Vecchio S. Les peches de la langue. Discipline et ethique de la parole dans la culture medievale. P., 2007.

8. Cicero M. Tullius. De re publica // De re publica, De legibus / ed. by C. W. Keyes. L., 1928.

9. Costa P. Iurisdictio. Semantica del potere politico nella pubblicistica medievale (1100—1433). Milano, 1969.

10. Decretum magistri Gratiani / ed. A. Friedberg. Lipsiae, 1879.

11. Godsall-Myers J. E. Speaking in the medieval world. Leiden; Boston, 2003.

12. Herriott J. H. The Ten Senses in the Siete Partidas // Hispanic Review. 1952. 20 (4). P. 269–281.

13. Isidor Hispalensis. De differrentiis: [Liber] I [= De differentiis verborum] / ed. par C. Codoner. P., 1992.

14. Isidor Hispalensis. Sententiae / ed. by P. Cazier. Turnholti, 1998 (CCSL; 111).

15. Kempshall M. S. De republica I.39 in medieval and Renaissance political thought // Cicero’s Republic / ed. by J. A. North and J. G. F. Powell. L., 2001. P. 99–135.

16. Las Siete Partidas del muy noble rey D. Alfonso el Sabio, glosadas por el lic. Gregorio Lopez del Consejo Real de Indias de S. M. Madrid, 1843.

17. Maravall J. A. Del regimen feudal al regimen corporativo en el pensamiento de Alfonso X // Estudios de Historia del pensamiento espanol. 1999. Vol. 2. P. 97–145.

18. Mitre Fernandez E. Mentira frente a la verdad en las disputas medievales entre catolicos y hereticos // Revista de Ciencias de Las Religiones. 2011. T. 16. P. 173–202.

19. Niederehe H.-J. Alfonso X el Sabio y la linguistica de su tiempo. M., 1987.

20. Peraldus W. Summa de vitiis // “Peraldus Project” / made by S. Wenzel, K. Emery, Jr., J. Goering, R. Newhauser [Ehlektronnyj resurs]. URL: http://www.unc.edu/~swenzel/peraldus.html (data obraschaniya: 13.10.2018).

21. Rubio Garcia L. En torno a la biblioteca de Alfonso X el Sabio // La lengua y la literatura en tiempos de Alfonso X. Actas del congreso internacional, Murcia, 5—10 marzo 1984. Murcia, 1985. P. 531—551.

22. S. Thomae Aquinatis. Scriptum super libros Sententiarum magistri Petri Lombardi episcopi Parisiensis. T. 3 / ed. par M. F. Moos. Parisiis, 1956. 2 vol.

23. Vecchio S. Mensonge, simulation, dissimulation. Primaute de l’intention et ambiguite du langage dans la theologie morale du Bas Moyen Age // Vestigia, imagines, verba: Semiotics and Logic in Medieval Theological Texts, XIIth — XIVth century. Acts of the XI Simposium on Medieval Logic and Semantics / ed. by J. Jolivet, C. Marmo. Turnhout, 1997. P. 117—132.

Comments

No posts found

Write a review
Translate