The Conquest of Ireland during the Age of Tudors and Early Stuarts: the Issues of Creation of Language Hierarchies
Table of contents
Share
Metrics
The Conquest of Ireland during the Age of Tudors and Early Stuarts: the Issues of Creation of Language Hierarchies
Annotation
PII
S207987840013467-2-1
DOI
10.18254/S207987840013467-2
Publication type
Article
Status
Published
Authors
Feliks Levin 
Affiliation: Higher School of Economics (Saint Petersburg)
Address: Russian Federation, Saint Petersburg
Abstract

The article is dedicated to the linguistic aspects of the conquest of Ireland during the age of Tudors and early Stuarts, which are examined from the perspective of establishment of power relations in British composite monarchy and through the prism of intellectual context. The author claims that the awareness of ethnocultural inequality was based on the complex attitude of medieval ethnographical knowledge to diversity, and emphasizes that distinctions were ideologized in the processes of establishing of power relations. The paper highlights two stages of state building in 16th — 17th centuries with distinct scenarios concerning the Irish language.  Initially, the English crown demonstrated tolerance to the Irish language in exchange for loyalty to its policy, but later, mainly because of the opposition of the local elites to the processes of expansion of central authority, stricter strategies of disciplining and controlling diversity began to prevail. As a result, around 1640-s functional hierarchy was established, according to which English was the language of social domination, and Irish was used for everyday matters.

Keywords
early Modern Ireland, Irish language, conquest of Ireland during the age of Tudors and early Stuarts, British identity, composite monarchy, language policy, medieval ethnography
Received
05.08.2020
Publication date
31.01.2021
Number of characters
41717
Number of purchasers
1
Views
42
Readers community rating
0.0 (0 votes)
Cite Download pdf 100 RUB / 1.0 SU

To download PDF you should sign in

Full text is available to subscribers only
Subscribe right now
Only article
100 RUB / 1.0 SU
Whole issue
1000 RUB / 10.0 SU
All issues for 2021
5000 RUB / 50.0 SU

References

1. Verner K. F., Gshnitser F., Kozellek R., Sheneman B. Narod, natsiya, natsionalizm, massa // Slovar' osnovnykh istoricheskikh ponyatij: Izbrannye stat'i v 2-kh t / sost. Yu. Zaretskij, K. Levinson, I. Shirle. T. 2. M., 2014. S. 378—466.

2. Mark Tullij Tsitseron. Tri traktata ob oratorskom iskusstve / pod red. M. L. Gasparova. M., 1972.

3. Fedorov S. E. Britanskaya identichnost' i kompozitarnaya monarkhiya v rannee Novoe vremya // Ehtnosy i «natsii» v Zapadnoj Evrope v Srednie veka i rannee Novoe vremya / pod red. N. A. Khachaturyan. SPb., 2015. S. 151—161.

4. Fedorov S. E. Byli li britantsy britantsami v rannee Novoe vremya? (tezisy vystupleniya) [Ehlektronnyj resurs]. URL: https://medieval.hse.ru/news/175193995.html (data obrascheniya: 30.12.2017).

5. Fedorov S. E. Identitarnye protsessy v srednevekovom Uehl'se: terminologiya, diskursy i situatsiya bilingvizma // Dialog so vremenem. 2017. Vyp. 61. S. 25—39.

6. Fedorov S. E. Rannestyuartovskaya aristokratiya. SPb., 2005.

7. Fedorov S. E. “Restored to the whole empire & name of Great Britaigne”: kompozitarnaya monarkhiya i ee granitsy pri pervykh Styuartakh // Imperii i ehtnonatsional'nye gosudarstva v Zapadnoj Evrope v Srednie veka i rannee Novoe vremya / pod red. N. A. Khachaturyan. M., 2011. S. 202—224.

8. Acts of the Privy Council of England Volume 34, 1615—1616 / ed. by E. G. Atkinson. L., 1925.

9. Bartlett R. Medieval and Modern concepts of race and ethnicity // Journal of Medieval and Early Modern Studies. 2001. Vol. 31. N. 1. P. 39—56.

10. Bliss A. The English language in early Modern Ireland // A new history of Ireland: Volume III, Early Modern Ireland 1534—1691 / ed. by T. W. Moody, F. X. Martin, F. J. Byrne. Oxford; N. Y., 2009. P. 547—561.

11. Braddick M. State formation in early Modern England, c. 1550—1700. Cambridge, 2004.

12. Bradshaw B. The English Reformation and identity formation in Ireland and Wales // British consciousness and identity. The making of Britain, 1533—1707 / ed. by B. Bradshaw, P. Roberts. Cambridge, 2003. P. 43—111.

13. Bradshaw B. The Irish constitutional revolution of the sixteenth century. Cambridge, 1979.

14. Brady C. From policy to power: the evolution of Tudor reform strategies in sixteenth-century Ireland // Reshaping Ireland, 1550—1700: colonization and its consequences: essays presented to Nicholas Canny / ed. by B. Mac Cuarta, N. P. Canny. Dublin, 2011. P. 21—42.

15. Brady C. The chief governors: the rise and fall of reform government in Tudor Ireland, 1536—1588. Cambridge, 2002.

16. Brady C. The government of Ireland, c. 1540—1583. Unpublished PhD Diss. Dublin, University of Dublin, 1980 [Ehlektronnyj resurs]. URL: http://www.tara.tcd.ie/handle/2262/77106 (data obrascheniya: 21.05.2018).

17. Burke P. Languages and communities in early Modern Europe. Cambridge, 2004.

18. Caball M. Pairlement Chloinne Tomáis I: a reassessment // Éigse. 1993. Vol. XXVII. P. 47—57.

19. Calendar of state papers relating to Ireland of the reign of Elizabeth. Vol. 2. 1574—1585 / ed. by H. C. Hamilton. L., 1867.

20. Calendar of the patent and close rolls of chancery in Ireland of the reigns of Henry VIII, Edward VI, Mary and Elizabeth. Vol. I. / ed. by J. Morrin. Dublin, 1861.

21. Canny N. P. Making Ireland British, 1580—1650. Oxford, 2001.

22. Crowley T. Wars of words: the politics of language in Ireland 1537—2004. Oxford, 2008.

23. Davies J. A discovery of the true causes why Ireland was never entirely subdued nor brought under obedience of the Crown of England until the Beginning of His Majesty's happy Reign (...) 1612 in Ireland under Elizabeth and James the First. L., 1890. P. 217—342.

24. Dictionary of national biography. Vol. XLII. O'Duinn-Owen / ed. by S. Lee. N. Y.; L., 1895.

25. Doyle A. A history of the Irish language: from the Norman invasion to independence. Oxford, 2015.

26. Edwards D. Collaboration without anglicization: the MacGiollaPadraig lordship and Tudor reform // Gaelic Ireland c. 1250 — c. 1650: land, lordship and settlement / ed. by P. J. Duffy. Dublin, 2004. P. 77—97.

27. Ellis S., Maginn C. The making of the British Isles the state of Britain and Ireland, 1450—1660. L., 2013.

28. Farrell G. The 'mere Irish' and the colonisation of Ulster, 1570—1641. Cham, 2017.

29. Flecknoe R. A relation of ten years in Europe, Asia, Affrique, and America all by way of letters occasionally written to divers noble personages, from place to place, and continued to this present year. L., 1656.

30. Gillespie R. Negotiating order in early seventeenth century Ireland // Negotiating power in early modern society: order, hierarchy, and subordination in Britain and Ireland / ed. by M. Braddick, J. Walter. Cambridge, 2001. P. 188—205.

31. Giraldus Cambrensis. Topografia Hibernica // Giraldi Cambrensis opera. Vol. V / ed. by J. Dimock. L., 1867. P. 3—201.

32. Greenblatt S. Renaissance self-fashioning from More to Shakespeare. Chicago, 1980.

33. Hastings A. The construction of nationhood: ethnicity, religion and nationalism. Cambridge, 1997.

34. Hodgen M. Early anthropology in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries. Philadelphia, 2011.

35. Holinshed R. The historie of Irelande. In 4 vol. Vol. 3. 1577 [Ehlektronnyj resurs]. URL: http://english.nsms.ox.ac.uk/holinshed/toc.php?edition=1577#vol-1577_3 (data obrascheniya: 12.07.2017).

36. Isidori Hispalensis episcopi. Etymologiarum sive Originum. Libri XX. In 2 t. / rec. W. M. Lindsay. Oxonii, 1911. T. I.

37. Iwanisziw S. Hugh O’Neill and national identity in early Modern Ireland // Anglo-Irish Identities, 1571—1845 / ed. by D. A. Valone, J. M. Bradburry. Lewisburg, 2008. P. 30—43.

38. Kane B. M. The politics and culture of honour in Britain and Ireland, 1541—1641. Cambridge, 2013.

39. Kidd S. British identities before nationalism: Ethnicity and nationhood in the Atlantic world, 1600—1800. Cambridge, 2004.

40. Mac Giolla Chríost D. The Irish language in Ireland: from Goídel to globalization. L., 2013.

41. Maginn C. “Surrender and Regrant” in the Historiography of Sixteenth-Century Ireland // The Sixteenth Century Journal. 2007. Vol. 38. N. 4. P. 955—974.

42. Montano J. P. The roots of English colonialism in Ireland. Cambridge, 2011.

43. Ó Cuív B. The Irish language in the early Modern Period // A new history of Ireland: Volume III, Early Modern Ireland 1534— 1691 / ed. by T. W. Moody, F. X. Martin, F. J. Byrne. Oxford; N. Y., 2009. P. 510—546.

44. Palmer P. Language and conquest in early Modern Ireland: English Renaissance Literature and Elizabethan imperial expansion. Cambridge, 2001.

45. Rich B. A new description of Ireland: wherein is described the disposition of the Irish whereunto they are inclined. No lesse admirable to be perused than credible to be beleeved: neither unprofitable, nor unpleasant to bee read and understood, by those worthy cittizens of London that be now undertakers in Ireland. L., 1610.

46. Rowland White's 'Discors Touching Ireland', c. 1569 / ed. by N. Canny // Irish Historical Studies. 1977. Vol. 20. N. 80. P. 439—463.

47. Salmon V. The study of language in 17th century England. 2nd ed. Amsterdam, 1988.

48. Smyth W. Map-making, landscapes and memory: a geography of colonial and early Modern Ireland c. 1530—1750. Cork, 2006.

49. Spenser E. A view on the present state of Ireland / ed. by R. Beare. Oregon, 1997 [Ehlektronnyj resurs]. URL: http://www.ucc.ie/celt/published/E500000-001/ (data obrascheniya: 20.01.2017).

50. Stuart royal proclamations, Volume I. Royal proclamations of king James I: 1603—1625 / ed. by J. F. Larkin, P. L. Hughes. Oxford, 1973.

51. The statutes at large, passed in the Parliaments held in Ireland: from the third year of Edward the Second, A. D. 1310, to the twenty sixth year of George the Third, A. D. 1786 inclusive with marginal notes , and a complete index to the whole / ed. by J. G. Butler, F. Vesey. In 13 vol. Vol. I. Dublin, 1786.

52. The Statutes of Kilkenny, 1366 // Irish Historical Documents, 1172—1922 / ed. by E. Curtis, R. B. McDowell. N. Y., L., 1968. P. 52—59.

53. Tudor and Stuart Proclamations: 1485—1714. Vol. II: Scotland and Ireland / cal. by R. Steele. Oxford, 1910.

54. Uniting the kingdom? The making of British history / ed. by. A.Grant, K. Stringer. L.; N. Y., 1995.