Russia, the Moscow Campaign and the Making of the Napoleonic Legend
Table of contents
Share
Metrics
Russia, the Moscow Campaign and the Making of the Napoleonic Legend
Annotation
PII
S207987840009098-6-1
DOI
10.18254/S207987840009098-6
Publication type
Article
Status
Published
Authors
Alan Forrest 
Affiliation:
University of York
State Academic University for the Humanities
Abstract

The Russian Campaign was a military disaster for Napoleon and was arguably the greatest strategic mistake of his career, greater even than the Peninsula or Waterloo. That he was able to recover his prestige with his army and with the French people owed much to his skills as a propagandist, and to his efforts, particularly during his exile on St. Helena, to prepare his legend and write his own history for posterity. For the officers and men involved, the Campaign brought pain, exhaustion, misery and death rather than the glory they had dreamt of; they returned to France decimated and dispirited, and for Napoleon himself a career of stunning victories was over. But not all was lost. This article examines the response of those who took part in the Russian Campaign to their experience of war, showing that though their faith in their Emperor’s strategy suffered, their loyalty to him remained largely intact. It also shows how much they admired the Russian troops against whom they fought, not least the Cossack horsemen, before their opinion of Russia and its people was undermined by the torching of Moscow. 1812 had been a disaster for Napoleon. Yet, the Russian Campaign would take its place in French memory as a glorious defeat and an emblematic adventure, breath-taking in its scale and ambition, and tragic in its outcome. Far from destroying Napoleon’s reputation, it may even have added an element of pathos and human fragility that contributed to the Imperial legend in the nineteenth century.

Keywords
historical memory, Napoleonic wars, Russian campaign of 1812, Napoleon
Received
17.11.2019
Publication date
12.06.2020
Number of characters
62727
Number of purchasers
5
Views
53
Readers community rating
0.0 (0 votes)
Cite Download pdf 100 RUB / 1.0 SU

To download PDF you should sign in

Full text is available to subscribers only
Subscribe right now
Only article
100 RUB / 1.0 SU
Whole issue
1000 RUB / 10.0 SU
All issues for 2020
1200 RUB / 24.0 SU

References

1. Assmann J., Czaplicka J. Collective Memory and Cultural Identity // New German Critique. 1995. № 65. P. 125—133.

2. Bainbridge S. Napoleon and English Romanticism. Cambridge, 1995.

3. Balzac H., de. Le médecin de campagne. Paris, 1949.

4. Beaucour F., Tabeur J., Ivtchenko L. La Bérézina. Une victoire militaire. Paris, 2006.

5. Belissa M. La Russie mise en Lumières: représentations et débats autour de la Russie dans la France du 18e siècle. Paris, 2010.

6. Bourgeois R. Tableau de la campagne de Moscou en 1812, par René Bourgeois, témoin oculaire. Paris, 1814.

7. Brégeon J. J. 1812. La paix et la guerre. Paris, 2012.

8. Broers M. Napoleon, Charlemagne and Lotharingia: Acculturation and the Borders of Napoleonic Europe // Historical Journal, 2001. № 44. P. 135—154.

9. Bulletins de la Grande Armée : Campagne de Russie 1812 / ed. par S. Le Couëdic. Paris, 1997.

10. Chuquet A. Human Voices from the Russian Campaign of 1812. L., 1994.

11. Colson B. Napoléon. De la guerre. Paris, 2011.

12. Dictionnaire des guerres et des batailles de l’histoire de France / ed. par J. Garnier. Paris, 2004.

13. Ducque G. Journal de marche du sous-lieutenant Ducque. Paris, 2004.

14. Epstein R. M. Napoleon’s Last Victory and the Emergence of Modern War. Lawrence, 1994.

15. Fain A. J. F. Napoleon: How he did it: The Memoirs of Baron Fain, First Secretary of the Emperor’s Cabinet. San Francisco, 1998.

16. Forrest A. Napoleon’s Men: The Soldiers of the Revolution and Empire. L., 2002.

17. Forrest A. Propaganda and the Legitimation of Power in Napoleonic France // French History. 2004. № 18. P. 426—445.

18. Forrest A., François E., Hagemann K. Introduction // War Memories: The Revolutionary and Napoleonic Wars in Modern European Culture. Basingstoke, 2012. P. 1—37.

19. Forrest A., Hagemann K., Rendall J. Introduction // Soldiers, Citizens and Civilians: Experiences and Perceptions of the Revolutionary and Napoleonic Wars. Basingstoke, 2009. P. 9—12.

20. Forth Ch. E. Masculinity in the Modern West: Gender, Civilization and the Body. Basingstoke, 2008.

21. Grève C., de. Le voyage en Russie. Anthologie des voyageurs français au 18e et 19e siècles. Paris, 1990.

22. Hantraye J. Le rapport à l’espace des soldats et officiers de l’armée impériale: expérience quotidienne, pratiques savantes et évocation des territoires conquis // Guerres et armées napoléoniennes : nouveaux regards / ed. par H. Drévillon, B. Fonck et M. Roucaud. Paris, 2013. P. 297—314.

23. Hantraye J. Les Cosaques aux Champs-Elysées. L’occupation de la France après la chute de Napoléon. Paris, 2005.

24. Hazareesingh S. The Legend of Napoleon. L., 2004.

25. Hennet L., Martin E. Lettres interceptées par les Russes durant la campagne de 1812. Paris, 1913.

26. Holtman R. Napoleonic Propaganda. Baton Rouge, 1950.

27. Houdecek F. La campagne de 1812 à travers des lettres de soldats // 1812, la campagne de Russie / ed. par M. P. Rey et T. Lentz. Paris, 2012. P. 145—154.

28. Hynes S. The Soldiers’ Tale: Bearing Witness to Modern War. L., 1997.

29. L’influence française en Russie au 18e siècle / Sous dir. de J. P. Poussou, A. Mézin et Y. Perret-Gentil. Paris, 2004.

30. Langeron A. L. A., de. Mémoires de Langeron, général d’infanterie dans l’armée russe, campagnes de 1812, 1813, 1814. Paris, 1902.

31. Largeaud J. M. Napoléon et Waterloo: la défaite glorieuse de 1815 à nos jours. Paris, 2006.

32. Las Cases E., de. Le Mémorial de Sainte-Hélène / ed. M. Dunan. Paris, 1951.

33. Le Gall D. Napoléon et le Mémorial de Sainte-Hélène. Paris, 2003.

34. Lieven D. Russia against Napoleon: The Battle for Europe, 1807 to 1814. L., 2009.

35. Markham D. J. Imperial Glory: The Bulletins of Napoleon’s Grande Armée, 1805—1814. L., 2003.

36. Mortimer G. Individual Experience and Perception of the Thirty Years War in Eyewitness Personal Accounts // German History. 2002. № 20. P. 141—160.

37. Moscou occupé: Lettres de soldats de Napoléon interceptées par les Cosaques, septembre-octobre 1812 / ed. par F. Houdecek and P. Le Carvèse. Fontainebleau, 2017.

38. Petiteau N. Lendemains d’Empire: les soldats de Napoléon dans la France du 19e siècle. Paris, 2003.

39. Pinault-Sørensen M. Impressions d’artistes français en Russie au 18e siècle // L’influence française en Russie au 18e siècle / sous dir. de J. P. Poussou, A. Mézin et Y. Perret-Gentil. Paris , 2004. P. 393—407.

40. Rey M. P. L’effroyable tragédie. Une nouvelle histoire de la Campagne de Russie. Paris, 2012.

41. Roberts A. Napoleon and Wellington. L., 2010.

42. Roos H., von. Avec Napoléon en Russie : souvenirs de la campagne de 1812. Paris, 2013.

43. Ségur Ph. P., de. La campagne de Russie, 1812. Paris, 2012.

44. Skuy D. Assassination, Politics and Miracles: France and the Royalist Reaction of 1820. Montreal, 2003.

45. Tussing Orwin D. Leo Tolstoy: pacifist, patriot, and molodets // Anniversary Essays on Tolstoy / ed. by D. Tussing Orwin. Cambridge, 2010.

46. Wolff L. Inventing Eastern Europe: The Map of Civilization on the Mind of the Enlightenment. Stanford CA, 1994.