Conflict Environment and Associative Spirit (Internal and External Communications at the Origins of the University of Paris)
Table of contents
Share
Metrics
Conflict Environment and Associative Spirit (Internal and External Communications at the Origins of the University of Paris)
Annotation
PII
S207987840002481-8-1
DOI
10.18254/S0002481-8-1
Publication type
Article
Status
Published
Authors
Pavel Uvarov 
Occupation: Senior Research Fellow
Affiliation: Institute of World History RAS
Address: Russian Federation, Moscow
Abstract
The formation period of the first, still spontaneous, universities lasted more than a hundred years. Numerous books and papers treat this process, but it remains unclear why it was precisely the corporative form that has prevailed over the others, the form that has determined the peculiar qualities of the western type of organization of intellectual activity as well as its further success. The usual references to corporatism inherent in medieval society, to the examples of craft and merchant guilds that could inspire the university masters and students, do not convince. It is well known that the scholars occasionally paid attention to the world of craft, but there is no evidence that the experience of craft and merchant associations could exert impact on urban intellectuals — who had set about their quest for organization even before the flourishing of craft corporations and merchant guilds. This article focuses on the emergence of the University of Paris whose history has been more fully studied than that of the majority of other universities. Should this process be called ‘natural’? One can speak about ‘origins’ that certainly had their own specific reasons. However, it is scarcely possible to establish a rigid causal connection between various reasons and motives. While considering each of the main episodes of this process it is necessary to take into account the intellectual conditions, the personal factors of the leading masters, as well as the particular distribution of forces both at the level of city authorities, secular and religious, and at the level of the Roman Curia. The exchange of experience with other proto-university centres, such as Bologna and Oxford, was likewise very important. All this notwithstanding, historians tend to underestimate the spatial factor, the evolution of the administrative structure of the local church, and the changes in the urban layout. It is probably not a mere coincidence that the construction of the wall of Philip Augustus was completed at the same time as the struggle of the masters for the recognition of their corporation markedly increased. An analysis of the situation may take into account the experience of Étienne Pasquier who had described the origins of the University of Paris at the turn of the 16th and 17th centuries. The «autogenesis» of the University of Paris seems more the result of a combination of unique circumstances and the exception rather than the rule. However, the form discovered in Paris was quickly picked up at other educational centers. The emergence of the University in Paris can be compared with other evolutionary breakthroughs in the history of mankind. Keywords: medieval universities, Parisian schools, University of Paris, university corporation, corporatism, communications, conflict, Bishop of Paris, Papacy, topography of Paris, process of territorialization.
Keywords
medieval universities, Parisian schools, University of Paris, university corporation, corporatism, communications, conflict, Bishop of Paris, Papacy, topography of Paris, process of territorialization
Received
17.08.2018
Publication date
31.10.2018
Number of characters
50422
Number of purchasers
33
Views
1228
Readers community rating
0.0 (0 votes)
Cite Download pdf 100 RUB / 1.0 SU

To download PDF you should sign in

Full text is available to subscribers only
Subscribe right now
Only article
100 RUB / 1.0 SU
Whole issue
1000 RUB / 10.0 SU
All issues for 2018
2500 RUB / 50.0 SU

References

1. Sidorova N. A. Ocherki po istorii rannej gorodskoj kul'tury vo Frantsii (k voprosu o reaktsionnoj roli katolicheskoj tserkvi v Srednie veka). M., 1954.

2. Suvorov N. S. Srednevekovye universitety. M., 1898.

3. Uvarov P. Yu. Pod svodami Dvortsa pravosudiya. Sem' yuridicheskikh kollizij vo Frantsii XVI v. M., 2017.

4. Fortinskij F. Ya. Bor'ba Parizhskogo universiteta s nischenstvuyuschimi monakhami v polovine XIII veka // Zhurnal Ministerstva narodnogo prosvescheniya. 1892, sentyabr'. S. 61—89.

5. Baldwin J. W. Masters, Princes and Merchants: The Social Views of Peter the Chantre and his Circle. Princenton: Princeton University Press, 1970. 2 vol.

6. Baldwin J. W. Philippe Auguste et son gouvernement / trad. de l’anglais de B. Boone. Paris, 1991.

7. Chartularium Universitatis parisiensis / ed. H. Denifle, Æ. Chatelain. Paris, 1889—1897. 4 t. (pereizd. — Bruxelles: Culture et Civilisation, 1964).

8. Crevier J.-B.-L. Histoire de l’Universte de Paris depuis son origine jusqu’en l’annee 1600. Paris, 1761. 7 vol.

9. Du Boulay S. E. Historia Universitatis Parisiensis. Paris, 1665—1673. 6 vol.

10. Dubois J., ‎Beaumont-Maillet L. Sainte Geneviève de Paris: la vie, le culte, l’art. Paris, 1982.

11. Fasoli G. Per la storia dell Universita di Bologna nel medio evo: Dalle lezioni tenute alla Facolta di Magistero nell’anno academico 1669—1670. Bologna, 1970.

12. Ferruolo S. C. The Origins of the University: The Schools of Paris and their Critics, 1100—1215. Stanford, 1985.

13. Gaulle J. de. Nouvelle histoire de Paris et de ses environs. Vol. 1. Paris, 1839.

14. Giordanengo G. Resistance intellectuelles autour de la decretale Super Speculam (1219) // Histoire et societe. Melanges offerts a Georges Duby. Vol. III: Le moine, le clerc et le prince. Aix en Provence, 1992. P. 141—155.

15. Gorochov N. Naissance de l’Universite. Les ecoles de Paris d’Innocent III a Thomas d’Aquin (1200—1245). Paris, 2012.

16. Grundmann H. Vom Ursprung der Universitat im Mittelalter. Berlin, 1957.

17. Hessel A. Geschichte der Stadt Bologna von 1116 bis 1280. Berlin, 1965. (Historische Studien; Bd. 76).

18. A History of the University in Europe. Vol. 1: Universities in the Middle Ages / ed. by H. de Ridder-Symoens. Cambridge, 1991.

19. Le Goff J. Les intellectuels au Moyen Age. Paris, 1957.

20. Loisel A. De l’Universite de Paris et qu’elle est plus ecclesiastique que seculaire. Paris, 1587.

21. Pasquier E. Les Recherches de France. Paris, 1621.

22. Rashdall H. The Universities in the Middle Ages. Oxford, 1895. 2 vol. in 3.

23. Southern R. W. From Schools to University // The History of the University of Oxford / ed. by T. H. Aston. Vol. 1. The Early Oxford Schools / ed. by J. I. Catto, R. Evans. Oxford, 1984. P. 1—36.