Inaccuracy in Details or Precisely Calculated Deception? Construction of Ideal Tyrant in Thomas More “History of Richard III”
Table of contents
Share
Metrics
Inaccuracy in Details or Precisely Calculated Deception? Construction of Ideal Tyrant in Thomas More “History of Richard III”
Annotation
PII
S207987840002397-5-1
DOI
10.18254/S0002397-5-1
Publication type
Article
Status
Published
Authors
Elena Braun 
Occupation: Assistant Professor
Affiliation: Russian State University for the Humanities
Address: Russian Federation, Moscow
Abstract
The purpose of this article is to reconstruct and analyze methods and technics, which Thomas More applied to turn Richard III into ideal tyrant. The analysis revealed five methods of distortion: transformation of Richard’ appearance; demonization of king’s character and soul; legalization of evil rumors; denigration of Richard’s confidants; revision of conventional conception that before his brother’s death Richard Gloucester was loyal vassal and respected man. In first three cases Thomas More used traditional and even standard for renaissance historiography technics. In two last — technics acceptable only in fiction, drama or political pamphlet. Indisputably More’s text is precisely calculated deception, but because of its literary skill, artfully composition and because More’s Richard III perfectly fits into the stereotypical image of ideal tyrant, in this case the credibility is more convincing than the truth.
Keywords
Thomas More, Richard III, Tudor myth, Wars of the Roses
Received
30.07.2018
Publication date
31.10.2018
Number of characters
41981
Number of purchasers
32
Views
1248
Readers community rating
0.0 (0 votes)
Cite Download pdf 100 RUB / 1.0 SU

To download PDF you should sign in

Full text is available to subscribers only
Subscribe right now
Only article
100 RUB / 1.0 SU
Whole issue
1000 RUB / 10.0 SU
All issues for 2018
2500 RUB / 50.0 SU

References

1. Barg M. A. Shekspir i istoriya. M., 1979.

2. Braun E. D. Richard III i ego vremya. M., 2016.

3. Kuznetsov E. V. «Istoriya Richarda III». Primechaniya // Tomas Mor. Ehpigrammy. Istoriya Richarda III. M., 1973. S. 439—454.

4. Baldwin D. Elizabeth Woodville Mother of the Princes in the Tower. Gloucester, 2010.

5. Baldwin D. Richard III. Stroud, 2012.

6. Candido J. Thomas More. The Tudor Chroniclers and Shakepeare’s Altered Richard // English Studies. 1987. № 68. R. 137—141.

7. Desmond S. Richard III: England’s Black Legend. L., 1983.

8. Grant P. Thomas More’s Richard III: Moral Narration and Humanist Method // Language and the Discovery of Method in the English Renaissance. L., 1985. R. 19—47.

9. Griffiths R. A., Thomas R. S. The Making of the Tudor Dynasty. Gloucester, 1985.

10. Grummitt D. A. Short History of the Wars of the Roses. L., 2014.

11. Hanham A. Richard III and his early historians, 1483—1535. L., 1975.

12. Hepbum F. Portraits of the Later Plantagenets. Woodbridge, 1986.

13. Hicks M. Edward V. L., 2003.

14. Hicks M. Anne Neville: Queen to Richard III. L., 2007.

15. Kendall P. M. Richard the Third. L., 1972.

16. Kinney D. Kings’ Tragicomedies: Generic Misrule in More’s History of Richard III // Moreana. 1985. № 86. R. 128—150.

17. Lehman J. S. Seeing Tyranny in More’s History of King Richard III // Moreana. 2013. Vol. 50 (Number 191—192). Is. 1—2. P. 131—157.

18. Lewis M. The Survival of the Princes in the Tower: Murder, Mystery and Myth. L., 2017.

19. More Th. The History of King Richard III / Online edition transcribed from W. E. Campbell’s facsimile of the Rastell edition of 1557 by Richard Bear at the University of Oregon, January-March 1997. URL: http://www.r3.org/bookcase/more/moretext.html (data obrascheniya 18.10.2018).

20. Myers A. R. Richard III and historical tradition // History. 1968. Vol. 53. Is. 178. P. 181—202.

21. Pollard A. J. Richard III and the Princes in the Tower. Gloucester, 1991.

22. Pollard E. F. Sir Thomas More “Richard III” // History. 1933. V. 17. P. 310—332.

23. Polydore Vergil. Anglica Historia (1555 version). Latin text and English translation / ed. and trans. by D. J. Sutton. Irvine, 2005. URL: http://www.philological.bham.ac.uk/polverg/contents.html (data obrascheniya 18.10.2018).

24. Portrait of Richard III by unknown artist. C. 1516, oil on panel (40 x 28cm). Society of Antiquaries.

25. Rous J. Joannis Rossi antiquarii Warwicensis Historia regum Angliae / ed. by Theatro Sheldoniano, impensis Jac. Fletcher & J. Pote, 1745.

26. Routh E. M. Sir Thomas More and his Friends, 1477—1535. L., 1934.

27. The reburial of King Richard III. The reburial week in Leicester in word and images for members of Richard III Society. Leicester, 2015.

28. Wagner J. A. Encyclopedia of the Wars of the Roses. Santa-Barbara, 2001.

29. Weir A. The Princes in the Tower. L., 1992.

30. What the bones can and can’t tell us // University of Leicecter oficial website. URL: https://www.le.ac.uk/richardiii/science/whattheonesdontsay.html (data obrascheniya 18.10.2018).